Vice President Kamala Harris’ recent small-business tax proposal has sparked a lively debate among economists, particularly those from conservative circles. While Harris advocates for reducing startup costs to stimulate new business growth, critics argue that her approach might be undermined by other tax policies. Let’s break down the controversy and explore the implications of Harris’ proposal for small businesses.
Harris’ Proposal: A Tax Break for Startups
Kamala Harris recently introduced a new proposal aimed at easing the financial burden on small businesses. Central to her plan is a significant increase in the standard tax deduction for startup costs. Currently set at $5,000, Harris’ proposal would raise this deduction to $50,000.
In her announcement, Harris framed this move as a substantial tax cut designed to help small businesses and innovators. “We’re going to help more small businesses and innovators get off the ground,” she stated.
Conservative Criticism: A Mixed Bag
Conservative economists have been quick to challenge Harris’ proposal. E.J. Antoni, a conservative economist, expressed scepticism about the effectiveness of the proposed tax deduction. According to Antoni, while the increased deduction might offer some relief, it could be offset by Harris’ concurrent plans to raise marginal tax rates for corporations and individuals.
Key Points of Conservative Critique
-
Conflicting Policies: Antoni argues that increasing the tax deduction while simultaneously raising tax rates creates a contradictory policy approach. “She wants to increase taxes on all kinds of income,” Antoni said. “No matter how the small business is structured, they will still be paying more.”
-
Historical Context: Antoni contrasted Harris’ approach with the Trump administration’s tax policies. Under Trump, tax cuts for businesses and individuals were implemented alongside increased deductions. Harris’ plan, however, appears to reverse this trend by raising taxes while expanding deductions.
-
Impact on Smaller Businesses: Richard Stern from The Heritage Foundation points out that the new deduction primarily benefits larger startups. “Harris’ new tax deduction for small businesses isn’t a subsidy for starting a business per se,” Stern explained. “It’s only useful if you actually spend $50K on pre-business expenses.”
Supportive Voices: A Different Perspective
Despite the conservative pushback, some supporters argue that Harris’ proposal is a positive step for small businesses:
-
Robert Wolfe’s View: Robert Wolfe, a former chairman of UBS Americas, supports Harris’ proposal. He argues that the increased tax deduction will benefit small businesses during their ramp-up phase, despite the potential tax rate increases for higher earners.
-
Rhett Buttle’s Perspective: Rhett Buttle, a former adviser for the Biden campaign, emphasises that Harris’ plan demonstrates a commitment to entrepreneurship. “The increased tax deduction proves Harris’ deep commitment to entrepreneurs,” Buttle said.
The Broader Economic Debate
Harris’ proposal is part of her broader “Opportunity Economy” economic platform, which aims to support small businesses and drive economic growth. However, the debate highlights the complexity of balancing tax incentives with broader fiscal policies.
Challenges and Considerations
-
Policy Integration: Integrating tax incentives with other fiscal policies is challenging. Critics argue that without a cohesive strategy, individual measures might be less effective.
-
Impact on Small vs. Large Businesses: The effectiveness of the proposed deduction depends on the size and expenditure of the business. Smaller startups may not benefit as much if their initial expenses are below the $50,000 threshold.
-
Political and Economic Impact: The proposal’s success will also depend on Congressional support and how it fits within the broader economic context.
Conclusion: What This Means for Small Businesses
Kamala Harris’ new small-business tax proposal aims to reduce startup costs and stimulate entrepreneurship. However, the mixed reactions from conservative economists reveal the complexities of tax policy and its implications for different business sizes.
While the increased deduction could offer significant benefits to larger startups, its effectiveness may be diluted by concurrent tax rate hikes. As the debate continues, it will be crucial for policymakers to consider how these measures interact and their overall impact on the small business ecosystem.
Relevant Links for Further Reading:
- Small Business Tax Deduction
- Economic Policy Debate
- Trump Tax Cuts
- Harris Economic Platform
- Impact of Tax Policies
