Israel’s creation in May 1948 was marked by a vision of equality and adherence to international law, as outlined in its Declaration of Independence. The founding document promised “complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race, or sex” and a commitment to the principles of the United Nations Charter. However, this vision has struggled to materialise. For nearly two decades post-independence, Palestinians lived under martial law, and the ideal of an inclusive democratic state has frequently clashed with the reality of a Jewish state prioritising its identity and security.
The Current Crisis: Israel at a Crossroads
Today, the war in Gaza and the associated judicial reforms have pushed Israel to a breaking point. The country is veering toward a future characterised by illiberalism, violence, and increasing authoritarianism. The current trajectory poses a significant threat to the humanist values that were intended to underpin the state’s foundation. Unless drastic changes are made, Israel risks becoming a pariah state, isolated internationally and plagued by internal turmoil.
The Fallout from the Gaza War
The brutal October 7 attack by Hamas occurred against a backdrop of severe domestic instability in Israel. The electoral system, with its proportional representation, has facilitated the rise of fringe and extreme parties. This instability is evident in the frequent changes in government and the disproportionate influence of minor parties. Since 2019, Israel has experienced five general elections, with the latest government, led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, relying heavily on far-right factions.
In 2023, Netanyahu’s push for a judicial reform bill aimed to diminish the Supreme Court’s oversight, ostensibly to protect himself from ongoing legal issues. His ultra-Orthodox allies sought to preserve exemptions for yeshiva students from military service, while religious Zionists aimed to limit the court’s authority over settlement construction. This controversial bill ignited massive protests, revealing a society deeply divided between those wishing to uphold democratic principles and those desiring unchecked governmental power.
The Shift Towards Authoritarianism
Israel’s path towards authoritarianism is marked by several troubling trends:
- Judicial Reforms and Civil Liberties: The judicial reform bill and subsequent legislation have sparked fears of diminishing democratic norms. With the Supreme Court’s recent ruling against parts of the reform, the government continues to push for changes that could further erode judicial independence.
- Increasing Violence and Authoritarian Measures: The Gaza conflict has provided a pretext for increasing state-sanctioned violence and restrictions on civil liberties. Recent legislation allows police to conduct searches without warrants, and there is growing hostility towards peace activists.
- International Isolation: Israel’s international standing is deteriorating. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Court (ICC) have issued criticisms and arrest warrants, further isolating Israel on the global stage.
The Potential for Internal Fragmentation
The rise of the far right, coupled with increasing domestic instability, could lead to severe internal fragmentation:
- Civil Unrest: The recent violent confrontation at the Sde Teiman detention facility highlights the growing divide within Israeli society. Attacks on military personnel by civilians and far-right parliamentarians are a troubling sign of escalating internal conflicts.
- Weakening Rule of Law: The potential breakdown of the rule of law could lead to a fragmented security system, with multiple groups claiming the right to violence. This scenario risks turning Israel into a failed state, plagued by internal strife and a collapsed economy.
A Path Away from Chaos
Despite these dire predictions, Israel has the capacity to alter its trajectory:
- Constitutional Reform: Establishing an independent constitutional commission to draft a more robust constitution could provide stability and reinforce democratic values. This would require significant cooperation across the political spectrum.
- Enforcement of the Rule of Law: Israel must address violence by settlers and end the military occupation of Palestinian territories. Engaging in a binding peace process with neutral third-party mediators is crucial.
- Strengthening Regional Ties: Building on the Abraham Accords and strengthening relations with Saudi Arabia and other regional allies could enhance Israel’s stability and global standing. Ensuring transparency and accountability in military operations is essential to restoring international confidence.
Conclusion
Israel stands at a critical juncture. The choices made in the coming months will determine whether the country can realign with the humanist values envisioned by its founders or descend further into authoritarianism and internal conflict. The path forward requires a commitment to democratic principles, a renewed focus on human rights, and a strategic effort to restore its international standing. It is not too late for Israel to redirect its course and preserve the vision of a just and equitable state.
Explore More:
