Haiti is on the brink of collapse. Political instability, rampant gang violence, and a humanitarian crisis have made life unbearable for many. Amid this turmoil, the election of Donald Trump as U.S. president raises questions about the future of U.S. support for Haiti, particularly in terms of aid and international intervention.
Trump’s historical stance on Haiti, marked by disparaging comments and a tough approach to immigration, has made many wonder how his second term might affect the beleaguered nation. Will Trump’s policies help stabilize Haiti, or will they exacerbate the suffering? Let’s explore how Trump’s election could shape U.S. involvement and the future of Haiti’s crisis.
Trump’s History with Haiti: A Troubled Relationship
During his first term, Trump made no secret of his disdain for immigration from Haiti. His remarks about Haitian migrants, including a false claim about Haitians eating pets, drew sharp criticism. But Trump’s policies were even harsher:
- Temporary Protected Status (TPS): Trump sought to revoke TPS for Haitians, a program that has allowed hundreds of thousands of Haitians to live and work in the U.S. after the 2010 earthquake.
- Immigration Hardline: His administration focused on curbing migration from countries like Haiti, especially in light of rising numbers of Haitian migrants fleeing violence and instability.
As a result, many Haitians living in the U.S. legally fear a return to an era of deportations and tightened immigration policies. This has raised concerns about the impact on Haiti, which relies heavily on remittances from its diaspora.
What’s Happening in Haiti Right Now?
Haiti is in the midst of a catastrophic crisis, one that’s been deteriorating for years. Some key facts include:
- Gang Violence: Gangs control up to 85% of Port-au-Prince, Haiti’s capital. They terrorise citizens with kidnapping, sexual violence, and killing.
- Political Instability: The assassination of President Jovenel Moïse in 2021 left the country without a stable government, and the situation has only worsened.
- Humanitarian Crisis: As of 2024, more than 5% of the population has been displaced. Food insecurity is rising, and cholera has resurfaced.
Haiti is also lacking effective governance. With no functioning government and a transitional body mired in corruption, there is little hope for stability in the near future.
What Does Trump’s Election Mean for Haiti?
Trump’s return to the White House could signal a sharp pivot in U.S. foreign policy towards Haiti. But the big question is: how will he respond to the mounting crisis?
Here’s what we can expect from his administration:
-
Immigration Policies: Deportations or Support?
- Trump has previously pledged to initiate the “largest deportation in U.S. history,” starting with Haitian migrants. If he follows through, it could destabilize Haiti further, as the country’s fragile economy and social services are ill-prepared to handle the return of thousands of migrants. Remittances, which account for about 20% of Haiti’s GDP, would also be severely impacted.
- Analysts suggest that mass deportations would only worsen Haiti’s economic collapse and deepen its humanitarian crisis.
-
Foreign Aid and U.S. Involvement in Haiti
- U.S. Support for the Kenya-Led Police Mission: Haiti’s transitional government has relied heavily on international support, particularly the Kenya-led policing mission that was set up to combat gangs. However, with limited resources and poor results, this mission has not been able to curb the violence.
- Trump’s administration might take a less interventionist approach to this mission, especially considering his “America First” stance. This could mean cuts to funding, leaving the mission underfunded and ineffective.
- If Trump prioritises “burden sharing” — a policy of demanding greater contributions from allies like the U.N. — it may slow down the progress of any peacekeeping force. Haiti’s government has called for a full U.N. peacekeeping mission, but resistance from countries like Russia and China may continue to undermine these efforts.
-
Aid Allocation and the Impact on the Haitian People
-
Trump’s attitude towards Haiti has often leaned towards the protection of U.S. interests, particularly immigration control. However, if the Haitian crisis worsens, even Trump may find it difficult to ignore the situation entirely. The U.S. could be forced into a difficult position: continue its support for international interventions, or allow the situation to worsen, potentially destabilising the entire Caribbean region.
-
With gang violence spiralling out of control, Trump’s administration may eventually realise that neglecting Haiti could lead to even larger issues for the U.S. (e.g., increased migration, regional instability).
-
The Road Ahead for Haiti: Is There Hope?
Despite Trump’s questionable stance on Haiti, some analysts believe the U.S. government may eventually have to intervene more directly in the region. The crisis in Haiti may become so dire that even the “America First” agenda will not be able to turn a blind eye.
-
Economic Impact: Haiti’s growing instability could lead to greater migration, with many Haitian refugees seeking refuge in the U.S. This may prompt the incoming Trump administration to adjust its immigration policies accordingly.
-
International Pressure: While Trump has been critical of international intervention, the growing humanitarian crisis in Haiti could make it impossible for the U.S. to avoid taking action — even if that means contributing to a U.N. peacekeeping mission or other multilateral efforts.
-
Haitians’ Hopes: For many Haitians, the best hope lies in a U.S. policy that supports humanitarian aid and allows for political solutions that come from within Haiti itself. If Trump’s administration listens to Haitian civil society and leads with pragmatism, there might be a chance for recovery.
Conclusion
In summary, Donald Trump’s return to the White House raises serious questions about the future of U.S. support for Haiti. His stance on immigration and foreign aid, combined with the deepening crisis in Haiti, could create a volatile situation that the new administration cannot afford to ignore.
Will Trump continue the U.S.’s long-standing policies that have failed Haiti, or will he take a different approach? Only time will tell, but one thing is certain: the future of Haiti’s stability rests heavily on the decisions made in Washington.
