The Menendez brothers, Lyle and Erik, have been behind bars for over three decades, convicted of the brutal 1989 murders of their parents, Jose and Kitty Menendez. However, after years of legal battles, there’s a renewed glimmer of hope for their release. This autumn, Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascón supported their bid for resentencing, a move that could potentially lead to their freedom. But will they get out? What’s next in this long-running case?
Let’s break it down.
The Menendez Brothers: What Happened in 1989?
In August 1989, the Menendez family was rocked by a horrific event. Jose and Kitty Menendez were found murdered in their lavish Beverly Hills mansion. The case quickly became a media sensation. Initially, authorities thought it was a mob hit. However, their sons, Lyle and Erik, soon became the prime suspects.
The twist? The brothers initially seemed genuinely distraught, calling 911 and reporting the deaths of their parents. But suspicions arose when their lavish spending and partying came to light.
The case took a dramatic turn when the brothers confessed to their psychologist. Unbeknownst to them, the psychologist’s girlfriend secretly recorded the confession, leading to their arrest.
The Trial: Admitting to the Murders, But Why?
During their 1993 trial, the Menendez brothers didn’t deny the murders but instead claimed self-defence. They argued that their father, Jose, had sexually abused them for years and that they killed him and their mother in a fit of fear and anger after confronting them about the abuse.
Both brothers gave emotional testimony, describing the years of emotional, physical, and sexual abuse they allegedly suffered at the hands of their father, a powerful figure in the Hollywood industry.
However, the prosecution argued that the true motive behind the killings was money: the $14 million inheritance. The brothers were convicted of first-degree murder in 1995 after a second trial.
The Growing Movement for Their Release
Fast forward to today, and the Menendez brothers’ case is gaining renewed attention, thanks to a Netflix documentary series and public interest surrounding their story. More than two dozen members of the Menendez family and celebrities, including Kim Kardashian, have publicly supported their bid for release.
Joan Anderson VanderMolen, Kitty Menendez’s sister, argued that if the trial had been held today, “the whole world wasn’t ready to believe that the boys could be raped,” but now, a jury would likely rule differently.
Yet, there’s division within the family. Some relatives, like Milton Andersen, Kitty’s brother, remain firm in their stance that the brothers should remain behind bars. His lawyer called the brothers “cold-blooded” and stated that their actions “shattered their family and left a trail of grief that has persisted for decades.”
The Resentencing: Could Freedom Be on the Horizon?
The biggest development in the case is the resentencing recommendation made by Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascón. Gascón, who is known for his progressive stance on criminal justice, supported the brothers’ request for resentencing, arguing that they should be eligible for parole due to their efforts at rehabilitation during their time in prison.
Here’s why the resentencing is crucial:
- Rehabilitation: Gascón pointed to the brothers’ accomplishments in prison, including their educational achievements and contributions to their community.
- Evolving Understanding of Abuse: He highlighted that today’s understanding of childhood sexual abuse is far deeper than it was during their trial, and if the case were tried today, their defence might have a better chance.
If the judge approves the resentencing request, the case would move to a parole board, where psychological evaluations, testimonies, and letters from the surviving family members would be considered.
However, the road ahead is rocky.
The Hurdles: Will They Ever Get Out?
-
Political Dynamics: Critics argue that Gascón’s involvement might have been motivated by his re-election bid. Nathan Hochman, Gascón’s successor, has promised to be tougher on crime. He’s already stated that he’ll carefully review the case and possibly delay the resentencing hearing scheduled for December 11.
-
Public Sentiment: The Menendez brothers’ case is deeply polarising. While many feel the brothers were the victims of long-term abuse, others believe the murders were driven by pure greed.
-
The Parole Board: If resentencing is approved, the parole board will ultimately decide their fate. They will review a variety of factors, including the brothers’ psychological assessments and the letters submitted by the victims’ surviving family members.
What If Resentencing Fails? Other Avenues for Freedom
Even if resentencing doesn’t go in their favour, the Menendez brothers have other potential routes to freedom:
-
Clemency: Defence attorney Mark Geragos has filed a clemency request with California Governor Gavin Newsom. Clemency could mean a reduced sentence or even a pardon, but it wouldn’t overturn their convictions. Newsom has stated that any decision will depend on the review of the case by the new district attorney.
-
Habeas Corpus Petition: The brothers also filed a habeas corpus petition, claiming that their convictions and sentences are unconstitutional due to new evidence. This includes:
- A letter Erik Menendez wrote to his cousin, detailing alleged abuse months before the murders.
- Allegations of sexual abuse by a former Menudo member, Roy Rosselló.
The petition seeks to vacate their first-degree murder convictions and possibly replace them with a lesser charge, such as manslaughter, which could lead to early release.
Their Life Behind Bars: Relationships and Personal Struggles
While behind bars, the Menendez brothers have led relatively active lives. Both have married while serving life sentences without the possibility of parole:
- Lyle Menendez: Married Rebecca Sneed in 2003, after a prison relationship. She has supported him throughout his incarceration.
- Erik Menendez: Married Tammi Saccoman in 1999 after a pen-pal relationship blossomed into a romance. Tammi has been outspoken in her support for Erik and even published a memoir detailing their relationship.
These relationships show a personal side to the brothers that many may not have considered before, offering a glimpse into their lives beyond the headlines.
